Rebirth, Reinvention, and Growing Pains
When Batwoman first premiered, it was a bold move for The CW’s Arrowverse. This was Gotham without Batman, anchored by a new protagonist: Kate Kane, Bruce Wayne’s cousin, fighting to fill the void he left behind. The first season was moody, gothic, and focused heavily on Kate’s personal demons, her family drama, and her eventual acceptance of the mantle of Batwoman.
But after just one season, Ruby Rose’s departure left the series at a crossroads. The creative team had a choice: recast Kate Kane, reboot the show entirely, or find a new way forward. They chose the riskiest option: to introduce a completely new character who would inherit the Batwoman mantle.
Enter Ryan Wilder.
Season 2 is, therefore, a unique creature: half-sequel, half-reboot, part meditation on legacy, part origin story for a brand-new hero. It’s a season that has to juggle mourning Kate Kane, introducing Ryan Wilder, and still delivering the Gotham crime drama fans expect. The result is ambitious, messy, emotional, and, by the time the finale rolls around, surprisingly rewarding.
Ryan Wilder: A Batwoman for a New Gotham
Ryan Wilder is not just a “new Kate Kane.” In fact, the writers go out of their way to make her the opposite of Kate in almost every conceivable way.
Where Kate was a military academy graduate, a member of Gotham’s upper crust, and Bruce Wayne’s cousin, Ryan is a foster kid who grew up with no safety net. Where Kate fought to uphold a family legacy, Ryan’s biggest fight is just to survive in a city that has failed her repeatedly.
Her backstory is a key strength of the season. Ryan’s foster mother was killed by gang violence, and Ryan herself was unjustly imprisoned for drug possession. When we meet her, she’s living in her van, trying to keep her life together. Finding the Batsuit is, in many ways, the first good thing that has happened to her in a long time. but also a source of pain, because she feels unworthy of wearing it.
Javicia Leslie brings Ryan to life with a combination of warmth, humor, and emotional depth. Ryan’s Batwoman is not as polished or as confident as Kate’s was in Season 1, and that vulnerability becomes part of her charm. Watching her grow into the role is one of the season’s best pleasures.
Season 1 vs. Season 2: Tone and Atmosphere
Season 1 of Batwoman was dark, brooding, and almost operatic. It was a story about grief: Kate mourning Beth (Alice) and the sister she once had, Jacob mourning the family he lost, Gotham mourning the disappearance of Batman. The tone was often heavy, and the season leaned heavily on psychological drama.
Season 2, while still dramatic, has a different flavor. It is more street-level, more grounded, and occasionally lighter in tone. Ryan’s personality brings a new energy to the show: she cracks jokes, has awkward moments, and approaches crime-fighting with a kind of scrappy ingenuity.
That tonal shift is not always seamless. There are episodes where the show can’t quite decide if it wants to be a gritty family drama or a campy superhero adventure. But the tonal variety is ultimately a strength, making the season feel less one-note than its predecessor.
Kate Kane’s Shadow
One of the season’s central challenges is how to handle Kate Kane’s absence. Instead of recasting her, the writers chose to weave her disappearance into the story. Kate’s plane crash becomes the inciting incident that sets the entire season in motion, affecting every member of the cast:
- Mary mourns her sister and throws herself into helping Ryan, becoming the heart of the Bat Team.
- Jacob Kane grows increasingly unstable, clinging to the Crows and using authoritarian tactics that drive a wedge between him and his daughters.
- Alice spirals as she refuses to accept Kate’s death, sending her on a revenge quest that ties into the Coryana storyline.
For Ryan, Kate’s shadow looms large. Even as she proves herself capable, there is always the question of whether Gotham truly sees her as Batwoman, or just as Kate’s stand-in. This tension drives much of Ryan’s arc, culminating in her decision to redesign the suit to reflect her identity.
By the time Kate eventually reappears, now played by Wallis Day, the show has largely established Ryan as the Batwoman. Kate’s return serves more as closure for the other characters, particularly Alice, rather than a full restoration of the status quo.
Gotham’s Systems on Trial
One of the strongest elements of Season 2 is its willingness to interrogate Gotham’s power structures. The Crows, Gotham’s private security force led by Jacob Kane, become more aggressive and authoritarian, and their corruption becomes impossible to ignore.
This is where Ryan’s perspective really matters. Unlike Kate, she has never been able to rely on the system. She knows what it’s like to be on the receiving end of unjust policing. The show doesn’t shy away from depicting the Crows as a stand-in for real-world policing issues: racial profiling, abuse of power, and militarized violence.
Sophie’s arc is particularly satisfying here. Over the course of the season, she becomes disillusioned with the Crows and ultimately leaves the organization, choosing to fight for justice outside the corrupt system. This decision feels earned and sets her up as a stronger ally for Ryan going forward.
Villains, Allies, and Character Work
Season 2 is packed with antagonists, which is both a strength and a weakness.
- Alice continues to be the show’s standout villain. Rachel Skarsten plays her with a perfect mix of menace and tragedy. The Coryana arc digs into Alice’s backstory, revealing her complicated relationship with Safiyah and adding layers to her character.
- Safiyah Sohail is an elegant and morally ambiguous villain whose storyline is more mythic than Gotham’s usual fare. Her connection to the Desert Rose, a rare plant with miraculous healing properties, gives the season a unique MacGuffin.
- Black Mask arrives in the back half of the season and turns the chaos up to eleven. He’s brutal, charismatic, and hellbent on taking over Gotham. While his arc is compelling, it sometimes feels rushed compared to the slower, more nuanced Coryana storyline.
The supporting characters also shine:
- Mary continues her growth from medical student to full-fledged hero, providing emotional grounding for the team.
- Luke Fox faces his own struggles, including a near-death experience that pushes him closer to becoming Batwing.
- Jacob Kane has one of the more tragic arcs, as his obsession with control leads to his downfall.
Strengths of Season 2
- Ryan Wilder’s Hero’s Journey: The season succeeds in making us root for Ryan. Her triumphs feel earned because we’ve seen her struggle.
- Thematic Boldness: The show engages with systemic injustice and institutional corruption in a way that feels timely.
- Alice’s Continued Complexity: Alice remains the most fascinating character on the show, and her evolving relationship with Kate gives the season emotional weight.
- Representation: Ryan Wilder’s presence as a queer Black woman leading a superhero series is groundbreaking, and the show treats her identity with respect.
- World-Building: Coryana, the Desert Rose, and Black Mask’s reign of terror expand Gotham’s mythology.
Weaknesses of Season 2
- Pacing Issues: Some episodes drag, while others feel overstuffed.
- Overcrowded Plotlines: With Safiyah, Alice, Black Mask, Kate’s disappearance, Snakebite, and the Crows, the season sometimes struggles to give each thread the attention it deserves.
- Tone Jumps: The mix of dark psychological drama and lighthearted superhero antics can be jarring.
- Kate’s Lingering Presence: While necessary for closure, the constant focus on Kate can feel like it undermines Ryan’s claim to the Batwoman mantle.
Season 1 vs. Season 2: Side-by-Side
| Aspect | Season 1 | Season 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Lead Character | Kate Kane: polished, wealthy, trained soldier | Ryan Wilder: scrappy, street-smart, outsider |
| Tone | Dark, gothic, psychological | More grounded, occasionally lighter, street-level |
| Main Theme | Legacy and grief | Identity and belonging |
| Villains | Alice as the emotional core; smaller rogues | Alice + Safiyah + Black Mask, multiple arcs |
| Gotham’s Systems | Crows as uneasy allies | Crows as outright antagonists |
| Character Growth | Kate grows into being Batwoman | Ryan proves she deserves to be Batwoman |
| Overall Feel | Gothic family drama | Rebirth story, reinvention |
This comparison shows how Season 2 is both a continuation and a reinvention. It honors what came before but ultimately moves toward a new direction.
The Finale and Future
By the finale, Ryan is no longer just the woman who found the Batsuit, she is Gotham’s Batwoman. The team has gelled, Luke is poised to become Batwing, Sophie is free of the Crows, and Alice’s fate leaves room for future stories. The season ends not with a reset but with a sense of momentum, positioning the show for an even stronger third season.
Final Verdict
Batwoman Season 2 is a fascinating experiment that mostly pays off. It’s not as sleek as it could be, and it occasionally buckles under the weight of its many plotlines, but it succeeds where it matters most: it makes Ryan Wilder a hero worth following.
If Season 1 was about Kate Kane embracing her destiny, Season 2 is about Gotham itself getting a second chance, and finding a new protector who represents the city’s resilience and diversity.
For viewers who were skeptical about the lead change, Season 2 is proof that the show could survive, even thrive, without Kate Kane at the center. It’s a season about rebirth, identity, and the courage to become someone new.
One Gay Astronaut 
Leave a comment